Who Were the Apostles?, Lesson 6: Bartholomew (Nathanael): An Israelite Indeed
Key text: John 1:47 (KJV)
Who Were the Apostles? A Bible study for men and women alike
Authorized Sword Ministries
Audio narrated with an AI voice. Read along below.
Welcome to Authorized Sword Ministries. This is Lesson 6 in our series, Who Were the Apostles? Today's lesson is called Bartholomew: An Israelite Indeed.
We're so glad you're here.
Today's apostle is a bit of a puzzle. Matthew, Mark, Luke, and Acts all list an apostle named Bartholomew, but they never tell us one thing he said or did. Meanwhile, the Gospel of John tells a wonderful story about a man named Nathanael, but John never mentions Bartholomew at all. Many Bible students believe these are two names for the same man. Today we'll look at the evidence honestly, and then we'll learn from what the Bible says about this man Jesus called "…an Israelite indeed…" (John 1:47).
Our Key Verse
Today's key verse is John 1:47.
— John 1:47 (KJV)
Guile means trickery, deceit, putting on a front. Jesus looked at Nathanael and saw an honest heart. What would Jesus say if He looked at yours?
Who Was Bartholomew?
Bartholomew is named in all four lists of the apostles:
— Matthew 10:3 (KJV)
See also Mark 3:18, Luke 6:14, and Acts 1:13. That's all the Bible tells us under the name Bartholomew. The name itself is generally understood to mean "son of Tolmai," a family name, the way Peter is called "…Simon Barjona…" (Matthew 16:17), meaning Simon son of Jona. So it would be natural for Bartholomew to have another personal name too.
Is Bartholomew the Same Man as Nathanael?
Here is the evidence, so you can weigh it for yourself.
Reasons many believe they are the same man:
- In Matthew, Mark, and Luke, Bartholomew's name is always paired with Philip's. In John, it's Nathanael who is paired with Philip, because Philip brought him to Jesus (John 1:45).
- John never mentions Bartholomew. The other three Gospels never mention Nathanael.
- Nathanael is clearly counted among the inner group of disciples. He was with Peter, Thomas, James, and John when the risen Lord appeared by the sea of Tiberias:
— John 21:2 (KJV)
What we must be honest about: The Bible never says, "Bartholomew, who is also called Nathanael." So this is a likely conclusion drawn from the verses, not something Scripture states outright. In this lesson we'll treat them as most likely the same man, while holding it loosely.
What we do know for sure is that Bartholomew was one of the twelve, chosen by the Lord after a night of prayer, and that God knows every one of His servants by name, even when we know very little about them.
Nathanael's Honest Doubt
When Philip told Nathanael that he had found the Messiah, "…Jesus of Nazareth…" (John 1:45), Nathanael wasn't impressed:
— John 1:46 (KJV)
Nazareth was a small, unimportant town. Nathanael himself was from Cana (John 21:2), just a few miles away, and he may have shared some of the local opinions about the next town over. He had a prejudice, and he said it out loud.
But here's what matters. Nathanael was willing to come and see. He was honest enough to say what he thought, and honest enough to go and check. God can work with a heart like that.
No Guile
As Nathanael walked up, Jesus spoke about him before he could say a word: "…Behold an Israelite indeed, in whom is no guile!" (John 1:47).
To a Jewish man, those words would bring to mind Jacob, the father of Israel, who was full of guile before God changed his name. When Jacob tricked his father, Isaac said:
— Genesis 27:35 (KJV)
Jacob had guile. But here was an Israelite with none. David wrote about the blessing of an honest, forgiven heart:
— Psalm 32:2 (KJV)
The Lord isn't looking for perfect people. He's looking for honest ones, men and women who don't hide behind a mask.
Under the Fig Tree
Nathanael was amazed:
— John 1:48 (KJV)
We don't know what Nathanael was doing under that fig tree. Perhaps he was praying, or reading the Scriptures, or thinking things over alone. Whatever it was, Jesus saw him there when no one else did. That was enough for Nathanael:
— John 1:49 (KJV)
Friend, the Lord sees you too, in your private places and quiet moments. David said:
— Psalm 139:1-2 (KJV)
Greater Things
Jesus told Nathanael that this was only the beginning:
— John 1:50-51 (KJV)
Again, Jesus pointed back to Jacob. Long ago, Jacob dreamed of a ladder reaching to heaven:
— Genesis 28:12 (KJV)
Jesus was telling Nathanael that He Himself is that ladder. He is the one way between heaven and earth. Nathanael, the honest Israelite, had found the true way to God.
Did Bartholomew Write Any Book of the Bible?
No. Neither the name Bartholomew nor the name Nathanael is attached to any book of the New Testament.
What the Bible Says and What Tradition Says
The Bible tells us Bartholomew was one of the twelve, and that he was in the upper room after the Lord went up into heaven (Acts 1:13). If he is Nathanael, we also know he saw the risen Lord by the sea (John 21:1-2). The Bible doesn't tell us where he went afterward or how he died.
Tradition, not Scripture: Different church traditions say Bartholomew preached in India, in Armenia, or in other lands, and that he was put to death for his faith. Those traditions don't agree with one another on the details, and none of them come from the Bible.
A Simple Step for This Week
Nathanael's story is about honesty. This week, ask the Lord to search your heart, using the words of Psalm 139:23-24. Is there any guile, any mask, any pretending in your walk with God or with others? Bring it to Him honestly. Then spend some quiet time alone with the Lord, your own "fig tree," and remember that He sees you there.
A Prayer
Let's pray together.
Heavenly Father,
Thank You for Bartholomew, faithful even though the Bible tells us so little about him. Thank You for Nathanael's honest heart, and for the way Jesus saw him under the fig tree.
Lord, take away the guile in us. Make us honest before You and before one another. Thank You that You see us in our quiet places. And thank You that Jesus is the way between heaven and earth, the only way to You.
In Jesus' name we pray. Amen.
Thank you for spending this time with us. Next time, we'll meet Thomas, an apostle known for his doubt, but also for one of the greatest confessions in the Bible.
This is Authorized Sword Ministries. God bless you.
Study Questions
- In which books is Bartholomew named, and what do they tell us about him?
- Give three reasons many Bible students believe Bartholomew and Nathanael are the same man.
- Why should we hold that conclusion carefully rather than state it as a fact?
- What was Nathanael's first reaction to hearing about Jesus of Nazareth (John 1:46)? What did he do next?
- What does "guile" mean? Why might Jesus' words in John 1:47 remind a Jewish listener of Jacob?
- What convinced Nathanael that Jesus was the Son of God (John 1:48-49)?
- How does John 1:51 point back to Jacob's dream in Genesis 28:12? What does it teach us about Jesus?
- Where is a quiet place where you can meet with the Lord this week?